Friday, November 17, 2017

Does this Houston personal injury attorney beg to be SLAPPed or what? Ivey Law Firm P.C. sues over unfavorable Google review (UPDATED)

12/29/2017 UPDATE: Mr Jack Todd Ivey non-suited this lawsuit on November 27, 2017 without prejudice to refiling. The Defendant had not yet been served when the presiding judge of the 157th District Court signed the dismissal order. 


Would you hire a lawyer if you knew that he would sue you for libel if you were dissatisfied with his services and said so in a public forum? 

A new low for the personal injury bar: Houston attorney Jack Todd Ivey sues poster of unfavorable customer review (apparently a family member of an unhappy former client) on per-se defamation theory, claiming to have been harmed by having his firm called "a fraud" in a Google review of his lawfirm. Let me suggest that the lawsuit will do more harm to the firm's reputation than the negative review, not to mention raising questions as to whether the positive reviews are genuine, and not manufactured or facilitated. 

Here is a screen shot of the Google Review and the owner's (Ivey's) response:




Lawsuit with textbook-example potential of how not to do law firm PR 



ALSO OF INTEREST: TEXAS ANTI-SLAPP STATUTE

The TCPA is often characterized as an "anti-SLAPP" statute, i.e., a means by which defendants targeted by "Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation," or SLAPP, suits can move for dismissal of such lawsuits. See id. § 27.002; see, e.g., Serafine v. Blunt (Serafine I), 466 S.W.3d 352, 365-67 (Tex. App.-Austin 2015, no pet.) (Pemberton, J., concurring) (summarizing TCPA legislative history and emphasis on "anti-SLAPP" concerns). The TCPA allows a motion to dismiss a "legal action" that is "based on, relates to, or is in response to a party's exercise of," as relates to this appeal, "the right of free speech." Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.003(a). The Act defines "the exercise of the right of free speech" as "a communication made in connection with a matter of public concern." Id. § 27.001(3). A "matter of public concern" is defined as, relevant to this appeal, "an issue related to . . . a good [or] product . . . in the marketplace." Id. § 27.001(7)(E). A "`[c]ommunication' includes the making or submitting of a statement or document in any form or medium, including oral, visual, written, audiovisual, or electronic." Id. § 27.001(1). The Texas Supreme Court has held that the Act protects both public and private communications. See ExxonMobil Pipeline Co. v. Coleman, 512 S.W.3d 895, 899 (Tex. 2016) (per curiam) (explaining its holding in Lippincott v. Whisenhunt, 462 S.W.3d 507, 509 (Tex. 2015) (per curiam)).

In enacting the TCPA, the legislature explained that its overarching purpose is "to encourage and safeguard the constitutional rights of persons to petition, speak freely, associate freely, and otherwise participate in government to the maximum extent permitted by law and, at the same time, protect the rights of a person to file meritorious lawsuits for demonstrable injury." Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.002. "To effectuate the statute's purpose, the Legislature has provided a two-step procedure to expedite the dismissal of claims brought to intimidate or to silence a defendant's exercise of these First Amendment rights." Coleman, 512 S.W.3d at 898. In the first step, the party filing a motion to dismiss under section 27.003 of the TCPA bears the burden to show by a "preponderance of the evidence" that the "legal action" is "based on, relates to, or is in response to," as relevant to this appeal, the party's "exercise of the right of free speech." Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §§ 27.003(a), .005(b); Coleman, 512 S.W.3d at 898. If the movant satisfies this burden, the trial court must dismiss the lawsuit unless the nonmovant "establishes by clear and specific evidence a prima facie case for each essential element of the claim in question." Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.005(c); see Coleman, 512 S.W.3d at 899. Even when the nonmovant meets this burden, however, the trial court still must dismiss the lawsuit if the movant "establishes by a preponderance of the evidence each essential element of a valid defense to the nonmovant's claims." Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.005(d); see Coleman, 512 S.W.3d at 899. In determining whether to dismiss an action, the trial court must consider "the pleadings and supporting and opposing affidavits stating the facts on which the liability or defense is based." Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 27.006(a); see Serafine I,466 S.W.3d at 357.

CIVIL PRACTICE AND REMEDIES CODE

TITLE 2. TRIAL, JUDGMENT, AND APPEAL

SUBTITLE B. TRIAL MATTERS

CHAPTER 27.  ACTIONS INVOLVING THE EXERCISE OF CERTAIN CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS

Sec. 27.001.  DEFINITIONS.  In this chapter:
(1)  "Communication" includes the making or submitting of a statement or document in any form or medium, including oral, visual, written, audiovisual, or electronic.
(2)  "Exercise of the right of association" means a communication between individuals who join together to collectively express, promote, pursue, or defend common interests.
(3)  "Exercise of the right of free speech" means a communication made in connection with a matter of public concern.
(4)  "Exercise of the right to petition" means any of the following:
(A)  a communication in or pertaining to:
(i)  a judicial proceeding;
(ii)  an official proceeding, other than a judicial proceeding, to administer the law;
(iii)  an executive or other proceeding before a department of the state or federal government or a subdivision of the state or federal government;
(iv)  a legislative proceeding, including a proceeding of a legislative committee;
(v)  a proceeding before an entity that requires by rule that public notice be given before proceedings of that entity;
(vi)  a proceeding in or before a managing board of an educational or eleemosynary institution supported directly or indirectly from public revenue;
(vii)  a proceeding of the governing body of any political subdivision of this state;
(viii)  a report of or debate and statements made in a proceeding described by Subparagraph (iii), (iv), (v), (vi), or (vii); or
(ix)  a public meeting dealing with a public purpose, including statements and discussions at the meeting or other matters of public concern occurring at the meeting;
(B)  a communication in connection with an issue under consideration or review by a legislative, executive, judicial, or other governmental body or in another governmental or official proceeding;
(C)  a communication that is reasonably likely to encourage consideration or review of an issue by a legislative, executive, judicial, or other governmental body or in another governmental or official proceeding;
(D)  a communication reasonably likely to enlist public participation in an effort to effect consideration of an issue by a legislative, executive, judicial, or other governmental body or in another governmental or official proceeding; and
(E)  any other communication that falls within the protection of the right to petition government under the Constitution of the United States or the constitution of this state.
(5)  "Governmental proceeding" means a proceeding, other than a judicial proceeding, by an officer, official, or body of this state or a political subdivision of this state, including a board or commission, or by an officer, official, or body of the federal government.
(6)  "Legal action" means a lawsuit, cause of action, petition, complaint, cross-claim, or counterclaim or any other judicial pleading or filing that requests legal or equitable relief.
(7)  "Matter of public concern" includes an issue related to:
(A)  health or safety;
(B)  environmental, economic, or community well-being;
(C)  the government;
(D)  a public official or public figure; or
(E)  a good, product, or service in the marketplace.
(8)  "Official proceeding" means any type of administrative, executive, legislative, or judicial proceeding that may be conducted before a public servant.
(9)  "Public servant" means a person elected, selected, appointed, employed, or otherwise designated as one of the following, even if the person has not yet qualified for office or assumed the person's duties:
(A)  an officer, employee, or agent of government;
(B)  a juror;
(C)  an arbitrator, referee, or other person who is authorized by law or private written agreement to hear or determine a cause or controversy;
(D)  an attorney or notary public when participating in the performance of a governmental function; or
(E)  a person who is performing a governmental function under a claim of right but is not legally qualified to do so.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.


Sec. 27.002.  PURPOSE.  The purpose of this chapter is to encourage and safeguard the constitutional rights of persons to petition, speak freely, associate freely, and otherwise participate in government to the maximum extent permitted by law and, at the same time, protect the rights of a person to file meritorious lawsuits for demonstrable injury.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.


Sec. 27.003.  MOTION TO DISMISS.  (a)  If a legal action is based on, relates to, or is in response to a party's exercise of the right of free speech, right to petition, or right of association, that party may file a motion to dismiss the legal action.
(b)  A motion to dismiss a legal action under this section must be filed not later than the 60th day after the date of service of the legal action.  The court may extend the time to file a motion under this section on a showing of good cause.
(c)  Except as provided by Section 27.006(b), on the filing of a motion under this section, all discovery in the legal action is suspended until the court has ruled on the motion to dismiss.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.


Sec. 27.004.  HEARING.  (a)  A hearing on a motion under Section 27.003 must be set not later than the 60th day after the date of service of the motion unless the docket conditions of the court require a later hearing, upon a showing of good cause, or by agreement of the parties, but in no event shall the hearing occur more than 90 days after service of the motion under Section 27.003, except as provided by Subsection (c).
(b)  In the event that the court cannot hold a hearing in the time required by Subsection (a), the court may take judicial notice that the court's docket conditions required a hearing at a later date, but in no event shall the hearing occur more than 90 days after service of the motion under Section 27.003, except as provided by Subsection (c).
(c)  If the court allows discovery under Section 27.006(b), the court may extend the hearing date to allow discovery under that subsection, but in no event shall the hearing occur more than 120 days after the service of the motion under Section 27.003.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.
Amended by:
Acts 2013, 83rd Leg., R.S., Ch. 1042 (H.B. 2935), Sec. 1, eff. June 14, 2013.


Sec. 27.005.  RULING.  (a)  The court must rule on a motion under Section 27.003 not later than the 30th day following the date of the hearing on the motion.
(b)  Except as provided by Subsection (c), on the motion of a party under Section 27.003, a court shall dismiss a legal action against the moving party if the moving party shows by a preponderance of the evidence that the legal action is based on, relates to, or is in response to the party's exercise of:
(1)  the right of free speech;
(2)  the right to petition; or
(3)  the right of association.
(c)  The court may not dismiss a legal action under this section if the party bringing the legal action establishes by clear and specific evidence a prima facie case for each essential element of the claim in question.
(d)  Notwithstanding the provisions of Subsection (c), the court shall dismiss a legal action against the moving party if the moving party establishes by a preponderance of the evidence each essential element of a valid defense to the nonmovant's claim.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.
Amended by:
Acts 2013, 83rd Leg., R.S., Ch. 1042 (H.B. 2935), Sec. 2, eff. June 14, 2013.


Sec. 27.006.  EVIDENCE.  (a)  In determining whether a legal action should be dismissed under this chapter, the court shall consider the pleadings and supporting and opposing affidavits stating the facts on which the liability or defense is based.
(b)  On a motion by a party or on the court's own motion and on a showing of good cause, the court may allow specified and limited discovery relevant to the motion.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.


Sec. 27.007.  ADDITIONAL FINDINGS.  (a)  At the request of a party making a motion under Section 27.003, the court shall issue findings regarding whether the legal action was brought to deter or prevent the moving party from exercising constitutional rights and is brought for an improper purpose, including to harass or to cause unnecessary delay or to increase the cost of litigation.
(b)  The court must issue findings under Subsection (a) not later than the 30th day after the date a request under that subsection is made.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.


Sec. 27.008.  APPEAL.  (a)  If a court does not rule on a motion to dismiss under Section 27.003 in the time prescribed by Section 27.005, the motion is considered to have been denied by operation of law and the moving party may appeal.
(b)  An appellate court shall expedite an appeal or other writ, whether interlocutory or not, from a trial court order on a motion to dismiss a legal action under Section 27.003 or from a trial court's failure to rule on that motion in the time prescribed by Section 27.005.
(c)  Repealed by Acts 2013, 83rd Leg., R.S., Ch. 1042, Sec. 5, eff. June 14, 2013.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.
Amended by:
Acts 2013, 83rd Leg., R.S., Ch. 1042 (H.B. 2935), Sec. 5, eff. June 14, 2013.


Sec. 27.009.  DAMAGES AND COSTS.  (a)  If the court orders dismissal of a legal action under this chapter, the court shall award to the moving party:
(1)  court costs, reasonable attorney's fees, and other expenses incurred in defending against the legal action as justice and equity may require; and
(2)  sanctions against the party who brought the legal action as the court determines sufficient to deter the party who brought the legal action from bringing similar actions described in this chapter.
(b)  If the court finds that a motion to dismiss filed under this chapter is frivolous or solely intended to delay, the court may award court costs and reasonable attorney's fees to the responding party.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.


Sec. 27.010.  EXEMPTIONS.  (a)  This chapter does not apply to an enforcement action that is brought in the name of this state or a political subdivision of this state by the attorney general, a district attorney, a criminal district attorney, or a county attorney.
(b)  This chapter does not apply to a legal action brought against a person primarily engaged in the business of selling or leasing goods or services, if the statement or conduct arises out of the sale or lease of goods, services, or an insurance product, insurance services, or a commercial transaction in which the intended audience is an actual or potential buyer or customer.
(c)  This chapter does not apply to a legal action seeking recovery for bodily injury, wrongful death, or survival or to statements made regarding that legal action.
(d)  This chapter does not apply to a legal action brought under the Insurance Code or arising out of an insurance contract.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.
Amended by:
Acts 2013, 83rd Leg., R.S., Ch. 1042 (H.B. 2935), Sec. 3, eff. June 14, 2013.


Sec. 27.011.  CONSTRUCTION.  (a)  This chapter does not abrogate or lessen any other defense, remedy, immunity, or privilege available under other constitutional, statutory, case, or common law or rule provisions.
(b)  This chapter shall be construed liberally to effectuate its purpose and intent fully.

Added by Acts 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., Ch. 341 (H.B. 2973), Sec. 2, eff. June 17, 2011.